Having recently reviewed a few of the more commonly used voting
systems that may be considered by the proposed committee to examine
electoral reform in Canada I thought it might be useful to collect
some examples of the type of ballot that such systems would require.
These examples are from various existing or proposed systems across
the world, it was surprisingly difficult to find good examples of
some types of ballots. Click on the examples to get a clearer view.
First up Mixed Member Proportional – Closed List where you have
one vote for your local representative and one vote for the partys
extra candidate of your choice. The Party chooses the individuals
needed to make up the number of MPs needed to satisfy the
proportionality of the vote.
Next up MMP – Open List where you have one vote for your local
represntitive and one vote for the partys extra listed candidate of
your choice. The individuals needed to make up the number of MPs
needed to satisfy the proportionality of the vote are decided by who
gets the most votes. I was unable to find an example of this type of
ballot but it would look something like this which is a combination
of the above and an open list proportional ballot.
The third example is that of a, Single Transferable Vote ballot
based upon a sample from the BC STV proposal, the instructions were
added from a Scottish STV ballot as no such information was included
in the original. It is the same as AV shown below in that you rank
the candidates except that the list contains the names of candidates
from 2 or more ridings and the one per riding are elected. Those who
win (using the ranked method of selection) represent the combined
district..
A far better example of an STV ballot is this one from the U.S.,
it has the additional quality of being machine readable, something
that I believe ALL ballots should encompass but particularly any that
have ranked voting.
Finaly we have this simple machine readable Alternative Vote,
Ranked Ballot (or whatever you wish to call it, I wish we could
settle on a common name for this voting method). Here you rank you
local candidates and your choices are taken into account when non of
the candidates get more than 50% of the #1 votes.
One final note here. In MMP all votes (for both the local
candidate and the Party or their choice list) are counted using First
Past The Post, there is nothing stopping one or both of these choices
being a ranked choice (except to make an already complex system more
complex) thus eliminating those with less than 50% of the vote from
automatically winning a seat. Such a ballot for Ranked MMP – Closed
list might look something like this.......
As with each voting method there are many different varietys of
ballots and what constitutes a valid or spoiled ballot as well as how
said votes are counted. Any proposal must include a sample ballot
which includes clear instructions on its use printed ON the ballot as
well as, where appropriate, exactly how that vote is distributed.
(i.e. The number of ridings represented in and STV ballot)
Support Democracy - Recommend this Post at Progressive Bloggers
A blog to give a voice to our concern about the continued erosion of our democratic processes not only within the House of Commons and within our electoral system but also throughout our society. Here you will find articles about the current problems within our parliamentary democracy, about actions both good and bad by our elected representatives, about possible solutions, opinions and debate about the state of democracy in Canada, and about our roles/responsibilities as democratic citizens. We invite your thoughtful and polite comments upon our posts and ask those who wish to post longer articles or share ideas on this subject to submit them for inclusion as a guest post.
Contact us at democracyunderfire@gmail.com
Contact us at democracyunderfire@gmail.com
Sunday, January 31, 2016
Sunday, January 24, 2016
Single Transferable Vote & Instant Run Off Voting
This week I will once again discuss some of the voting
systems that may
be considered for our future electoral reform.
Single transferable vote (STV) is often touted as a “proportional”
system, it is not, it is merely Instant Run Off (otherwise known as
Alternative Vote or AV) with a wider choice of candidates by
combining several ridings and having voters indicate their choice of
candidates in order of preference. The representatives for the 2 or 3
or 4 ridings are then selected using the instant run off method from
the combined list of candidates.
That is:-
An STV election starts with every voter's first choice, according to the following steps:
The advantage of this system compared with MMP (proportional) alternatives is that the number of elected MPs remains the same as the number of existing ridings (even after they have been combined for voting purposes) however for those who are determined to have a fully proportional system this will not produce such results despite it being described as 'somewhat proportional' in many write-ups. There are no 'extra' MPs and thus no artificial limits upon national votes that eliminate a smaller party from equal opportunities or any method to make the results 'proportional' with the popular vote.
The problem with STV in a country a large and diverse as ours with some riding’s covering hundreds of square miles is that whilst combining ridings and electing multiple representatives to cover that area may work in urban areas, in other parts of the country it could result in the election of MPs totally unconnected with distant parts of the combined riding and the wishes of larger centres within the combined district overriding those of the more distant areas. The combination of just 3 ridings in my rural area (in SW Ont) would result in a riding of more than 14, 000 sq km twice the size of the GTA with its 58 seats, this would be a 'small' riding compared with some other areas of the country. This system is only partly proportional anyway.
As mentioned above STV is merely Instant Run Off (AV) but with combined ridings.
AV (instant runoff) where your second and third choices are taken into account in electing a single LOCAL MP work exactly the same but just one MP is selected from the resulting voter preferences, otherwise all remains the same, I now (having previously voted for MMP in the Ontario referendum) personally flavor this way (AV / Instant Runoff) of electing our local representative (even within a proportional system should that happen, i.e. AV+), it is after all a known and well used system used by political party’s and others to elect leaders. It is the 'first past the post' thing that has everybody complaining about it so why would we still elect out local MP this way as most MMP systems do? It does not (except in its 'plus' format) add to the number of MPs in the HoC. It is not proportional in the true sense but may reflect the wishes of more electors in perhaps electing their second choice and does to some extent let folks spread their votes between a choice of person and party. It is also simplifies the ballot compared with most other systems and may be better understood by the general public..
For clarity AV+ is basically MMP but with the local candidates selected by an Instant Run Off method. Any system which calls upon voters to select or rate multiple candidates and / or party representatives will by default require a much more complex ballot and a more robust method of counting (and selecting the winners from preferential lists) than currently employed. If you thought the line ups were too long during the recent election wait till you have to rate candidates in order or select multiple candidates or select 'party candidates' as well as local ones.
As I have said before, I am all for voting reform but fear that it is not as simple as some would believe and some of the choices may well come with voter confusion, more spoiled ballots, longer line ups, more results challenged due to not understanding counting methods etc etc. I do not envy the “committee' in their work to 'recommend' a replacement system to FPTP!
One final note, there has be some commentary that this system or that give advantage to this party or that, I do not believe this is the case. Taking past results and applying them to a new method of voting tells us nothing. With each method and voter choices the voter selections made may have very little to do with past preferences and no one can predict the outcome, which is perhaps the single best thing about the change.
Support Democracy - Recommend this Post at Progressive Bloggers
That is:-
An STV election starts with every voter's first choice, according to the following steps:
- A candidate who has reached or exceeded the quota (usualy
50%) is declared elected.
- If a candidate has more votes than the quota, surplus votes
are transferred to other candidates. Votes that would have gone to
the winner go to the next preference.
- If no-one new meets the quota, the candidate with the fewest
votes is eliminated and those votes are transferred.
- This process repeats until either a winner is found for every
seat or there are as many seats as remaining candidates.
The advantage of this system compared with MMP (proportional) alternatives is that the number of elected MPs remains the same as the number of existing ridings (even after they have been combined for voting purposes) however for those who are determined to have a fully proportional system this will not produce such results despite it being described as 'somewhat proportional' in many write-ups. There are no 'extra' MPs and thus no artificial limits upon national votes that eliminate a smaller party from equal opportunities or any method to make the results 'proportional' with the popular vote.
The problem with STV in a country a large and diverse as ours with some riding’s covering hundreds of square miles is that whilst combining ridings and electing multiple representatives to cover that area may work in urban areas, in other parts of the country it could result in the election of MPs totally unconnected with distant parts of the combined riding and the wishes of larger centres within the combined district overriding those of the more distant areas. The combination of just 3 ridings in my rural area (in SW Ont) would result in a riding of more than 14, 000 sq km twice the size of the GTA with its 58 seats, this would be a 'small' riding compared with some other areas of the country. This system is only partly proportional anyway.
As mentioned above STV is merely Instant Run Off (AV) but with combined ridings.
AV (instant runoff) where your second and third choices are taken into account in electing a single LOCAL MP work exactly the same but just one MP is selected from the resulting voter preferences, otherwise all remains the same, I now (having previously voted for MMP in the Ontario referendum) personally flavor this way (AV / Instant Runoff) of electing our local representative (even within a proportional system should that happen, i.e. AV+), it is after all a known and well used system used by political party’s and others to elect leaders. It is the 'first past the post' thing that has everybody complaining about it so why would we still elect out local MP this way as most MMP systems do? It does not (except in its 'plus' format) add to the number of MPs in the HoC. It is not proportional in the true sense but may reflect the wishes of more electors in perhaps electing their second choice and does to some extent let folks spread their votes between a choice of person and party. It is also simplifies the ballot compared with most other systems and may be better understood by the general public..
For clarity AV+ is basically MMP but with the local candidates selected by an Instant Run Off method. Any system which calls upon voters to select or rate multiple candidates and / or party representatives will by default require a much more complex ballot and a more robust method of counting (and selecting the winners from preferential lists) than currently employed. If you thought the line ups were too long during the recent election wait till you have to rate candidates in order or select multiple candidates or select 'party candidates' as well as local ones.
As I have said before, I am all for voting reform but fear that it is not as simple as some would believe and some of the choices may well come with voter confusion, more spoiled ballots, longer line ups, more results challenged due to not understanding counting methods etc etc. I do not envy the “committee' in their work to 'recommend' a replacement system to FPTP!
One final note, there has be some commentary that this system or that give advantage to this party or that, I do not believe this is the case. Taking past results and applying them to a new method of voting tells us nothing. With each method and voter choices the voter selections made may have very little to do with past preferences and no one can predict the outcome, which is perhaps the single best thing about the change.
Support Democracy - Recommend this Post at Progressive Bloggers
Wednesday, January 20, 2016
Gone tilt!
New content on this site has been temporally suspended due to a computer failure and the time and effort needed to reinstall everything on a new one. Normal service will be restored as soon as possible!
See http://ruralcanadian.blogspot.ca/2016/01/things-that-piss-me-off.html Support Democracy - Recommend this Post at Progressive Bloggers
See http://ruralcanadian.blogspot.ca/2016/01/things-that-piss-me-off.html Support Democracy - Recommend this Post at Progressive Bloggers
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





